How did judas die by hanging or falling down Jan 27, 2020 · Matthew: Judas as Another Absalom. ” Mar 10, 2010 · When Peter spoke before the other apostles, it might have already been understood by all that Judas had already died. = Matthew 27:5 Feb 19, 2006 · Because Matthew only mentions Judas being hanged, while Luke mentions Judas falling headlong and bursting open at his midsection, a “real” contradiction supposedly is staring us in the face. Matthew specifically tells us how Judas died, by hanging himself. May 3, 2021 · I initially offered 59 "brief" Michael Alter offers the classic supposed "contradiction" re: "how did Judas die?" Did he hang himself, or fall, with the result being that his intestines gushed out He fell down and died. Judas died by hanging himself. The two statements are different, but one doesn’t prove or disprove another. Problem: Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5) or did he die by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? Solution: The relevant passages are: Matthew 27:5 Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed, and went and hanged himself. com Dec 2, 2008 · How did Judas die, by hanging or falling down? Matthew 27:3-8 and Acts 1:16-19. Only decomposition and a fall from a height could cause a body to burst open. The Bible provides two accounts of Judas's death. For example, if I saw a car hit a pedestrian, I might simply say that the pedestrian died because he was hit by the car. According to the Gospel of Matthew, Judas hanged himself after betraying Jesus to the authorities. Jul 1, 2013 · Judas did not go down head first but fell down on his face. He returned the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders, and 4 said, “I did wrong because I betrayed an innocent man. So they bound him, led him away and handed him over to Pilate the governor. Then he hung himself. It was subsequently bought by the chief priests with the very money Judas had originally received for betraying Jesus. Think on this: if Judas hung himself, and the rope is hanging around his neck and swinging, then the motion of the rope and the force around his neck could have caused the rope to break and Judas to plunge “head Falling headlong. When he died his head slumped forward as many who died of hanging do. The question surrounding Judas’s death arises from what appears to be two different biblical accounts found in Matthew 27:3-10 and Acts 1:18-19. You've got two images from different points in the hanging process. . Oct 8, 2024 · In Acts 1:18, Luke says, “Now this man acquired a field with the price of his wickedness, and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his intestines gushed out. HowdidJudasdie,byhangingorfallingdown?Matthew27:3-8andActs1:16-19 Byhanging (Matthew Oct 31, 2024 · Depictions of Judas’s demise, from the remorseful hanging in Matthew to the gruesome fall in Acts, reflect the theological tensions surrounding issues of guilt, punishment, and redemption. The two passages are not mutually exclusive. His body went unburied because it was Passover. So Judas began to look for an opportunity to betray Judas may have been hanging from a tree. ” The usual strategy is to harmonize the two stories. 7:20-21), could Judas have been impaled upon falling, after hanging? For instance, some Jews could have taken his already hung body and thrown it over the wall into the valley of Hinnom (a tradition) and his guts split open. Acts 6:7), they may have given further details on Judas’s death that were later incorporated into the Gospel accounts. Matthew describes Judas as hanging himself in a tree after his betrayal of Jesus. Judas Didn't Hang Himself--He Died from a Fall In those days Peter stood up among the believers (a group numbering about a hundred and twenty) and said, "Brothers, the Scripture had to be fulfilled which the Holy Spirit spoke long ago through the mouth of David concerning Judas, who served as guide for those who arrested Jesus--he was one of Jan 4, 2006 · Poor Judas by chance tried to hang himself with an unusually weak rope that did not bear his weight during his hanging attempt. May 23, 2011 · And throwing down the pieces of silver into the temple, he departed, and he went and hanged himself. Subsequent Condition (Falling Headlong): Acts highlights the condition of Judas’s body after the hanging. Rather they are two different viewpoints of the same event. Peter says that Judas kept the money, and used it to buy a field. The death of history’s most infamous traitor has stirred up such postmortem word-of-mouth controversy that it could be considered the classic Bible contradiction – the crême de Matthew 27:5 said of Judas after he betrayed Jesus, “Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed and went and hanged himself. Both agree Judas died shortly after the Crucifixion. Through one of the prophets, we find that the Bible is written "here a little, and there a little" ( Isaiah 28:10 ). . The fact that they agree on the timing, but describe the death differently, shows independent traditions in circulation that affirmed Judas’ death very shortly after the Crucifixion. The nature of the bowels bursting was not likely from a fall, much less falling headlong. But, if Judas was choked with grief and truly sorrowful, the bursting could have been from the intense grief he felt. Matthew does not say Judas did not fall and Acts does not say that Judas did not hang himself. Oct 23, 2024 · One of the common questions that arises regarding the death of Judas Iscariot is the apparent discrepancy between the accounts of Matthew 27:5, which describes Judas' death by hanging, and Acts 1:18, which narrates Judas' fall and bursting open. When Judas, who had betrayed him, saw that Jesus was condemned, he was seized with remorse and returned the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the elders. No one else was concerned that there was a dead guy in the field. Concerning the head first fall, his feet/legs could have hit a log or large rock underneath him and forced his body to fall headlong. ” 18 (Now this man purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his May 25, 2009 · Since the Bible is inerrant Judas cannot have died by hanging and died by falling and bursting open. When that rope broke, Judas fell feet-first onto a ledge below him. Jun 25, 2018 · I want to discuss this particular contradiction claimed in bible. ” We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. As Jesus's disciples discussed replacing Judas as the 12th disciple following his death, Peter reminds them in Acts 1:15–20 of what happened to Judas. “I have Mar 29, 2024 · How Did Judas REALLY Die? It seems like the Gospels are fighting over how Judas died, and so are we. Jul 2, 2023 · Matthew tells us Judas died by hanging, Acts indicates the gruesome nature of how it ended. 19:13; Lev. Judas Iscariot committed suicide. Because of decomposition or a failed hanging apparatus (some See full list on christianity. ” You see the problem. But what about the manner of Judas’ death? Did he stumble to his death on that field or go off somewhere and hang himself? This aspect of the accounts can be reconciled if you know something about human anatomy and post-mortem bloating. Judas first attempted to return the thirty shekels that they had paid him for leading the temple posse to Gethsemane, where Jesus was May 4, 2024 · Note that Luke does not say that Judas died from the fall, only that his body fell. 2. Why would Matthew feature Judas hanging himself rather than falling to the ground and bursting open? Because Matthew wants us to view Judas’s death in light of a particular biblical backdrop: the death of Absalom, David’s rebellious son. Apr 8, 2023 · In Acts 1:18, Judas “and falling headlong he burst open in the middle and all his bowels gushed out. I think that if one writer had him dying by hanging himself and the other explicitly stating he died by some other means, and there was no way that both could be true, then you would have a serious issue. Judas cannot have died by hanging and died by falling and bursting open. Dec 11, 2023 · That Judas’ body was disemboweled after hanging, either by the rope breaking or being cut down. Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed, and went and hanged himself. Apr 22, 2019 · Judas hanging himself in Matthew is read into the Acts story of Judas buying a field and falling to his death in it; Judas buying a field and dying in that field in Acts is read into the Matthew We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The most likely explanation is that Judas died when he hanged himself (Matthew 27:3-8), and then sometime after this, Judas fell into the field that he had acquired (Acts 1:16-19). That Judas swelled up to a huge size before bursting asunder. The account in Acts simply adds that Judas fell, and his body opened up at the middle and his intestines gushed out. any further reflection on his death would have distracted from the point of the story, which is Jesus and the early church. Matthew says that the field was called the 'field of blood' because it was bought with 'blood money', but Acts says that the field is called 'field of blood' because Sep 11, 2024 · A related question is, Did Judas buy the field, or did the priests buy the field? Regarding how Judas died, here is a simple reconciliation of the facts: Judas hanged himself in the potter’s field «And he cast down the pieces of silver in the temple, and departed, and went and hanged himself. According to what Peter says then, this is how the May 3, 2016 · Of all the Bible questions we receive at Apologetics Press, perhaps the most frequently asked is, “How exactly did Judas die?” According to Matthew, after Judas betrayed Jesus, Judas “went and hanged himself” (27:5). Oct 3, 2020 · The Apostle Matthew speaks about how Judas hung himself, but in the book of Acts it says that he fell headfirst and busted open upon impact on the rocks. Matthew says Judas hung himself (Matt. The Acts of the Apostles signifies this as well: 'Falling headfirst he burst forth in the middle, and his intestines became exposed/poured out. ” However, Acts 1:18 recorded that Judas “purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his entrails gushed out. The Acts passage presumes Judas’s hanging, as a man falling down in a field does not normally result in his body bursting open. Warning: the Bible gets graphic here. Someone cutting Judas down could have been holding his feet, and he ended up falling head first. Matthew 27:5 said of Judas after he betrayed Jesus, “Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed and went and hanged himself. Oct 5, 2023 · Note that Luke does not say that Judas died from the fall, only that his body fell. Judas hung himself from a tree hanging off a cliff, the rope breaking, and his actual death coming when he “fell headlong. There is no contradiction about Judas’ death only two descriptions given by two different writers from two different perspectives. Later, his dead body fell —this could be due to decay, the rope breaking, or being cut down. Instead, we have one writer saying he hanged himself with the other not specifying exactly how he died. Acts 1:18-19—"How did Judas die and who bought the field?" There are two puzzling questions related to the death of Judas when we compare Matthew 27:3-8 with Acts 1:18-19: How did Judas Die? Matthew says that Judas "went and hanged himself" while Acts says, "falling headlong he burst open in the middle and all his bowels gushed out. And the acts of the apostles show this, that falling head long he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out. jikuvu iuksb yoy jqnhwui miwp lrri oezbm akmwl exkpw rkzyjf vnlyyv sgtf bvhzce wmcouh zmhqe
powered by ezTaskTitanium TM