Unequal inheritance reddit It's insidious the way children with offspring think they should get a larger percentage of an inheritance, cus kids. But it is the thought of being treated unfairly that gets me. My reasoning is our youngest has used all of her inheritance in the money we are constantly having to give her. Please read our rules before commenting. Husband’s mother is a strange one. You should independently seek legal advice from a real, qualified practitioner. And suppose the daughter who gets the 100% inheritance, gets married to a person, and unfortunately she passed away for some reason. Disregarding the financial responsibility of the patriarch in this discussion amounts to dishonesty. Your older son is not getting an inheritance- his wife is. Let's review what OP has said about Jake. It's costing us a huge capital gains penalty, because typically, my parents set up ownership in the fastest cheapest way possible. Now, her husband will get all inheritance accidentally provided they don’t have any children. Now, as the parents are gone, the full responsibilities goes to her uncles. My uncle made the call to break the trust and just give both me and my brother our portions of the inheritance. He: thinks he's not getting enough of the inheritance, has guardianship over those with a near-majority of the assets, So, Reddit, am I the asshole by feeling hurt and resentful about this unequal inheritance plan? Should I just suck it up and be grateful for whatever I receive, or is it fair for me to express my disappointment? Your judgments will help me gain some perspective on whether I'm being a reasonable person or an entitled brat. Would you adjust your estate planning if you had one kid who was richer than the others? Trying to stay vague to avoid self-doxxing (throwaway acct of course), but my spouse and I have a child (Kid A) who is on pace for a $5m NW by age 30. Unequal split on inheritance with siblings? So my mother (may she rest in peace) had a life insurance policy that pays out to me, my sister, and brother equally. India went through a reformation to protect female inheritance. Watch this video by Mufti about the concept of trajectory hermeneutics to know why Islam has to reflect the age it's in. " Stepdad died last year, and my brother and I shared $600,000 when we sold the crumbling, rat infested house. However, I’m curious to know your Opinion on a parent (70M) who leaves more (including their house) in their will to the “unsuccessful” kid (40F) justifying it by saying “she needs more help than you (33F) and your brother (43M) do. So Hindu inheritance law differs in BD and India. Can I contest an unequal inheritance? My mom passed and she distributed the remainder of her ROTH IRA between me (her daughter), my dad, and my brother (her son). 1 Goat Aqiqah for a girl and 2 for a boy, inheritance, witness. The truth is that the inheritance law in Islam is skewed to partially help the burdened patriarch. Seems VERY unequal to me, but Jake complaining about his share despite his family unit basically getting half is gross. As Hinduism differs greatly across regions, I'll try to simplify it. Recently, out to dinner out of the blue she tells me that she and father in law are updating their will and husband’s older brother will get more money than us. An inheritance isn't mandatory, the bio father's side could leave the kids nothing, or they could blow through their money and then there is nothing. They had an inheritance that could have been passed down to the next generation and kept the family secure for a long time, but they squandered it in 5 years. If you want to donate 100% to charity, you can. e. 5 years. I like to think I'm not a materialistic person, but the message this sends to me has hurt me. I expect to inherit somewhere in the 100-200k range. Ok- I refuse to fight over “things” and I won’t with this . The not well off isn't any reason to use one child's share of inheritance to subsidise the others lifestyle choices. The only inheritance that's any kind of sure thing that OP can count on is what he's leaving behind, anything else is an ASSumption which is never a good idea. Often, if a male paternal lineage exists (say your male cousin from your dad's side, and you have no brothers), then you would be completely excluded from inheritance. I myself am one of four fully related children, with our inheritance split simply between the four of us. However she left 50% to my brother and split the remainder between me and my dad. Fun fact: This also has classical precedents. everything their parents worked for their entire lives). YTA - your younger son and DIL are getting their inheritance from you already. AITA for breaking off relations with my family because of unequal inheritance, while I am treated second-class and expected to have the responsibility for health-related issues of my parents? I'm a 32F living in Spain, originally from Germany. The way things were set up would prevent my brother from getting his portion of the inheritance for about 18 months, and keep me from mine for 6. Why would you leave as much money to your youngest daughter, Sonia, a real-estate lawyer with a high six-figure salary and no kids, as you would to your older son, Roberto, a semi-employed Yeah, his kids weren’t “entitled” to his inheritance, but he was just so shitty about everything. Anyone claiming women being treated unfair by the inheritance laws just wants something to criticize Islam for. Why they keep having children they can't afford says a lot their mindset about money. . My stepdad said "that's your inheritance, don't ask for more. The Same way I deal with any other form of inheritance, farm prestige like crazy and switch the duchy titles to elective ones, maintain no vassals in the duchies that are elective or only have house members as vassals for free hooks to use if needed to swing elections in your favor. ” Unfortunately, there is a pattern of giving half to women compared to men. It might be better to get them financial management classes - they count on you paying. I did divide out my jewelry equally and several other items for them and when we pass they are to sell our home and equally split it. In my experience inheretences should be equally split amongst children and then they can pass to their children as they see fit. Jens Magnusson/Getty Images. Leaving unequal inheritance is a great way to make surviving siblings resent each other. Welcome to r/AusLegal. My wife and I both work decent jobs (her around 100k, me around 150k) and plan to continue working unless an octo-mom situation arises. We ( my husband and I) divided out inheritance and our eldest got most of it. Feb 19, 2021 · The growth in stepfamilies is a major reason the percentage of Americans 50 and older who left their children unequal bequests more than doubled, to nearly 35 percent in 2010 from 16 percent in Jun 9, 2022 · An unequal estate plan may seem perfectly logical on paper, but financial experts think it may cause more problems than it solves. It’s your money. She passed suddenly about 10 days ago, and we are just beginning to get through her files, etc. Learn about budgeting, saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning… Feb 27, 2025 · A Reddit user with a $6 to $7 million net worth is currently trying to determine how best to divide up an inheritance among his two kids when he passes away and he’s not sure how to proceed Mar 11, 2022 · Second, one sibling might be wealthy enough that an inheritance wouldn’t make much difference for him or her when it could be life-changing for the other(s). She is a traditional Asian woman, her father (aka my grandpa) didn't leave any inheritance to her and her sisters, but his sons (my uncles) get everything. " We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Please remember: Per rule 4, this subreddit is not a replacement for real legal advice. The inheritance is not a lot of money either. Third, one kid might have received more from the parents along the way—for grad school, a house down payment, whatever—and the will feels like a way to even this out. On the surface, it makes perfect sense. She’s highly manipulative to say the least. I understand that there are arguments to justify these Islamic practices, but those arguments have never satisfied me to start believing that these rules establish justice and equality. That guy doesn't talk to his family anymore - the money ruined a lot of relationships. Clearly, then,you think affection correlates with money! But ultimately, what does pulling away from the relationship communicate about this? Unequal inheritance has to go and so does lashing and hand-cutting - the latter two were in fact pre-Islamic pagan practices. She said that the inheritance will now be split 4 ways instead of 2. Jan 25, 2017 · Speaking of which, I'm confused how one can say "it's not about money!" and in the next breath say that unequal distribution of inheritance indicates unequal affection. I never understood the people who thought they were entitled to an inheritance (i. (He is completely entangled with his parent It shouldn't be to the detriment of one of her children that the other one produced 3 children. If the parents want to help M21 (who I believe is writing this post) with some funding for medical treatment or a house that would be reasonable since they're helping the other siblings with college, but to leave an unequal inheritance they're bound to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 19M subscribers in the personalfinance community. ucqbvwjqondkvnhwuvuwqqncvukiqppernricpqzkgqaaxrkedsqymysxvqaolaldpixnmrfcevscfi