Why didn t arthur cough on micah.
Contraction didn’t necessarily mean certain death.
Why didn t arthur cough on micah Thoughts? Apr 27, 2023 路 @Nilpferd218In the trivia section on Micah's page it mentions that Micah seems to have respiratory problems, constantly snorting, clearing his throat, and coughing. Jul 11, 2023 路 Does Arthur know he has TB? Does Arthur get laid in RDR2? What does Arthur’s grave say low honor? What happens if Arthur dies with low honor? Why does Arthur cough so much RDR2? Why is Hosea coughing RDR2? Can you avoid Arthur getting sick? Why does Dutch shoot Micah? Could Arthur have survived RDR2? Will RDR3 be a prequel to RDR2? Micah get's Arthur down like he's gonna finish him and Arthur just grabs him by the jacket, pulls, him in and coughs in the damn rat's face. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming deadstringsof Aug 20, 2020 路 Given how contagious tuberculosis is, it's a wonder that Arthur didn't infect anyone in the Van der Linde camp after becoming sick in RDR2. He is always the biggest talker and easily the biggest jerk in the Van der Linde gang's camp. Arthur’s physical strength, superior Jun 16, 2024 路 Why didn t Dutch help Arthur? All of Arthur’s protest and resistance was concern for Dutch and the gang, but Dutch was too convinced of betrayal and disloyalty to believe Arthur, and it didn’t help with Micah poisoning him constantly against the others. Jul 26, 2023 路 Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Nov 27, 2018 路 There are a multitude of reasons why his wife (probably) didn't get TB but are not limited to: Downes knowing he had TB and avoided spreading it to his family, Downes simply not coughing on his family, etc. I didn't see the point of the cough if it wasn't going to tie into something down the road, and in the back of my head I was like "it would be so rockstar to kill Arthur this way". In this article, we’ll delve into the motivations behind Micah’s actions and explore the complexities of their relationship. Also gang code. (Edited by Wagwan piffting23) 3 Dakota9513·1/14/2021 Just coughing into his face probably wouldn’t have done much. 4 chapters later, Arthur is confirmed by a doctor to have tuberculosis. Dutch openly accuses Arthur and John of betrayal towards the end of things and Arthur surely My guess is that Dutch and Micah were not together since Arthur's death, and Dutch uses the promise of the Blackwater money to lure Micah out of hiding so he can kill him. E. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming nipsofodinyt 289,783 The best thing would have been for Arthur to cough and spit in Micah's face. 2 Loyalty44rogue·5/3/2023 I really should've listened in Health class. Why didn t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn't serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). For Downes he didn't just cough on Arthur I believe he spit in his face. Why didn't Arthur retaliate when Micah shot Grimshaw? Basically the same reason John did not retaliate in RDR when Dutch tried to provoke John by calling Abigail a whore. It was only a matter of time, and Arthur didn't have the luxury of taking it easy to delay the inevitable. This is because tuberculosis weakened Morgan’s immune system and made him more susceptible to other illnesses and infections. Could Arthur have survived tuberculosis? Arthur didn’t need a diagnosis to tell him that he was going to die; even if he somehow escaped being shot or hanged, his death is an inevitability. It seems the best way to do that would be to kill at the very least Micah and possibly Dutch too. Apr 28, 2022 路 The first and most obvious thing players will say about Red Dead Redemption 2 's story is that, had Arthur not fallen ill, he wouldn't have died. I think that would have been a nice F**** you to all of those Black Lung and Coughing Billy insults. Abigail and Sadie found out in the last mission too when Arthur told Milton when he asked him about his cough. So Micah could have had TB and never even noticed (and also not infected no one). page on May 16, 2025: "Why didn’t Arthur cough in Micah’s face . As much as Sadie, John, Mary-Beth, Tilly etc like Arthur they don't seem to give a shit about his well being. Could have saved John his whole revenge arc, though. Arthur likely got it from the droplets expelled by Downes, there wouldn’t need to be any blood in that interaction. Arthur convinces Dutch to abandon Micah and leave. There is the obvious "cough of death", which sounds horrifyingly painful and includes blood. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Why didn't Micah *spoilers*". The question isn’t really if Arthur Morgan could defeat Micah Bell without the debilitating effects of tuberculosis, but how thoroughly. Reply reply ryanash47 • Funny enough it was in Thomas “do-gooder” Downes’ character to do such a thing Reply reply [deleted] • Its a slow and painful death Reply reply Infect Micah with Tuberculosis? All he had to do was spit some blood into him (ie exactly the same way Arthur got TB in the first place from Mr. ) Why didn t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn't serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). Dec 31, 2019 路 Why is Arthur coughing so much? I think i'm nearly done with chapter 4 and i've noticed Arthur keeps coughing. Tell me if I’m wrong but other than Mary Beth and Sadie I don’t think anyone in the gang was concerned about Arthur’s health heck they didn’t even acknowledge that he was sick. Thomas coughs blood on Arthur. page . Arthur may have anticipated this, and chose rather not to. Red Dead Redemption Art 馃尩 RDR Merch 馃憠 @rdr. At that point Dutch cared more for Micah than Grimshaw if anyones argument is "then why didn't Dutch shoot Micah after killing Grimshaw". Evidence from Gameplay: Hosea's persistent cough and illness, as highlighted in camp conversations, suggest a possible link to Arthur's condition, adding credibility to this Why didn t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn't serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). Unlike Downes, Arthur had manners and didn’t cough in people’s faces. When John asks Dutch why he’s there, he replies, “Same reason as you, I suppose. Credits to arthur_morgan_rdr2_1899 on At that point in the story, Micah was just an annoying mouthy asshole. Now, years later, Dutch Van Der Linde arrives at Micah’s wanting to kill him. Aug 4, 2023 路 No; getting sick is integrated into the story. Even in the later stages, where he's coughing up blood, you have to be fairly close to him to catch it from his Why does Micah leave Arthur to die in High honor and and personaly kill him in Low honor. But once Arthur has TB, it's not really guarenteed that he gives it to anyone else. Mar 6, 2023 路 Arthur begs John to return to his family. Following the point above this, why didn't anyone Arthur interact with get TB? He coughed quite close to them. Also, Arthur does tell a few people in camp, and we all know that word spreads fast. But even if he never told anyone, and all Micah had to go off of was the cough, the nickname or term of "Black Lung" does not refer specifically to TB. To me, with the time I spent doing the challenges and collecting pelts, my Arthur didn't get to Saint Denis until like late June- mid July. It’s why Dutch tells John Marston he’s there for the same reason John is. It’s my understanding that Dutch didn’t stick with Micah after Arthur’s death and was only there at the epilogue to kill Micah. Why did Dutch take Micah’s side? Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang John . ” (Probably not the exact quote, but somewhere along those lines. That's where the "black lung" thing started. A healthy Arthur Morgan, unburdened by the ravages of TB, would have dominated Micah in virtually any confrontation. Jan 29, 2025 路 Why Didn’t Dutch Save Arthur from Micah? Red Dead Redemption 2’s narrative is filled with moments of intense drama and tragedy, and one of the most pivotal and heartbreaking scenes is when Arthur Morgan is betrayed and killed by Micah Bell. Nov 3, 2018 路 Arthur didn't have the diagnosis yet so I don't know if this was a glitch that made Micah say that earlier of if he was just making fun of the cough. Why didn t anyone catch TB from Arthur? For the sake of the story, Arthur contracted it from Thomas Downes, but it is really a big stretch of the imagination that Arthur did not pass his germs onto other people in close proximity. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming rd2. Bam, you've got TB. Ironically, despite it taking eight years, Arthur’s greatest weapon against Micah was spreading news of his betrayal to the rest of the gang, which is ultimately what sealed Micah’s fate. Arthur got very unlucky and also lived a very hard life. He obviously has no qualms about killing people and he knew Micah was breaking up the gang. Many have tried to skip the mission: you can’t. If you were low honor Arthur, it would've made sense. The vengeful Micah soon ambushes him, and Dutch intervenes. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming doggofcb 25,494 May 15, 2023 路 How did Arthur not infect others? Because Arthur isn’t Thomas Downes. What does the Honor matter for Micah. Maybe Arthur didn't want to tell Dutch about it since he had already gone crazy and it wouldn't have made any difference. Knowing Micah, if he knew he had contracted TB, he'd have gone on a rampage shooting up everyone in a town or simply coughing in their face before he died, thus spreading the disease. Micah Bell is one of the most ruthless characters in Red Dead Redemption 2, so why didn’t he finish off High Honor Arthur? Was it fear, arrogance, or something deeper? In this video, we break Why didn't Arthur just cough on Micah then ? I thought he would do so at the end of the fight May 17, 2025 路 Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah intentionally? The article indicates that Arthur was self-aware of his condition and likely tried to avoid coughing on anyone, even before his official diagnosis. Because Arthur is, as Sean puts it, a doubter. Anyways, when I first played A Fork in the Road that sprung to my mind as the doc examined Arthur. Not to mention that Arthur was on his last legs trying to take down micah and using all his strenght to do so Thinking about spitting and wasting energy and time on that during that situation probably didnt even occure to him. memes 479,779 During the mission, "Money Lending and Other Sins (part 3) in Chapter 2. This is when Arthur is exposed/infected with Tuberculosis. Why didn’t Arthur cough in Micah’s face . Feb 16, 2022 路 Micah Bell is the most dangerous enemy that Arthur Morgan meets in Red Dead Redemption 2, but he's certainly not the toughest, as he loses multiple fights to other members of Dutch's gang throughout the game. Jul 18, 2020 路 Perceptive fans finally answer one of the most burning, lingering questions about one characters fate in the Red Dead Redemption 2 ending. When he doesn't and for your next mission you're milking cows it's really jarring because despite everything seeming peaceful you know Micah is still out thereso you're still gripped in finding the end to the story. Jan 7, 2025 路 Key Takeaways Challenging the Narrative: The theory that Hosea might have infected Arthur with tuberculosis questions the traditional belief that Thomas Downs was responsible, offering a fresh perspective on the storyline. So yeah, Micah likely did get some blood on him from Arthur, but that certainly didn’t mean he was assuredly dead. The question of why Dutch didn’t save Arthur from Micah is a complex one, rooted in a Why didn t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn't serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). The factors that contributed to Micah’s victory were heavily influenced by Arthur’s declining health, coupled with the circumstances of the fight itself. In a particular mission, Arthur coughs as a sign of his illness. Regardless of his feelings towards those people. I also believe he coughs early on to distract the player from when he gets the TB. Apr 27, 2025 路 Why Dutch Didn’t Save Arthur From Micah: A Tragedy of Pride, Betrayal, and a Shattered Legacy The climactic confrontation between Arthur Morgan, Micah Bell, and Dutch van der Linde in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a gut-wrenching culmination of years of brotherhood, loyalty, and ultimately, betrayal. The short exchange between Arthur and Thomas seems minuscule in the context of Red Dead Redemption 2 's Apr 28, 2024 路 Also, it's like @billiejoearmstrong8 said, Downes had tuberculosis and he was getting beat up by Arthur, he was gonna cough eventually and it just happened to be when they were face to face to each other, even Arthur acknowledged this and didn't beat him more for this reason, people back then probably didn't even know what a bacterium was, let Why didn’t Arthur cough in Micah’s face . Apr 8, 2023 路 Why does Micah hate Arthur? The thing is that, if you look back when Arthur got to the shore of Guam’s, you’d see that Micah seems to be pretty excited of his survival too, the truth is that Micah didn’t hate Arthur, he never did, it was first cowardice, as he ratted out the whole gang fearing to be killed, which eventually changed him. If Arthur continues to have low honour then he sees Arthur as more of a threat and decides not to risk leaving him alive. So maybe your right and Micah actually did have a form of non-fatal tuberculosis which would be really ironic. Would Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick? Why didn’t Arthur cough in Micah’s face . Credits to arthur_morgan_rdr2_1899 on tiktok . Without tuberculosis, he wouldn't be coughing Jul 5, 2020 路 Despite being basically polar opposites, Red Dead Redemption 2's protagonist Arthur Morgan and antagonist Micah Bell share something in common. Micah says early on in the game that he looks up to Arthur. One of Arthur's main character traits is loyalty to the gang and those in it. Dutch and Micah I understand because of the plot but even then, Micah openly mocks Arthur for being ill and Dutch doesn't care at all. My only problem was why didn't Arthur just shoot Micah when they were out and about. He also kept some distance from them whenever he began coughing. 66K likes, 188 comments - rdr. Also Micah wasn’t in Dutch’s ear fully by this point, so Dutch wouldn’t have thought of Arthur as a traitor. "You don't know where I've been Lou" style from Fight Club. Feb 19, 2025 路 Why Did Micah Shoot Arthur in the Face? The Red Dead Redemption 2 community has been buzzing with questions about the events leading up to Micah’s fateful decision to shoot Arthur Morgan in the face. . The character "Thomas Downes" coughs blood into Arthur's face. What year is RDR2 set? Arthur was weak ,i dont think he would be able to shoot Micah. Why didn't Dutch save Arthur? In the battle against the US Army with the Indians, Dutch seemingly left Arthur to die, believing that a “disloyal“ Arthur was no longer any use for him. Arthur doubts everything, every plan, every idea, every person, because that’s simply who he is. Yeah, as a few people have mentioned, they knew about it but there was literally no sympathy from anyone in the gang and that really got to me. Dutch was going crazy and Micah was the one supporting and manipulating him while Arthur was angering him, shooting Micah would've made Dutch attack him. That's why Arthur gets it from that dude, he's beating his ass, and then the guy coughs and it sprays blood into Arthur's eyes. Jun 15, 2023 路 Why did Dutch take Micah’s side? What mental illness does Dutch have in RDR2? Can I leave Micah in jail? Why does Micah have a scar on his eye? Could Arthur have killed Micah without TB? Could Arthur beat Micah without TB? Why is Hosea coughing RDR2? Was Arthur mentioned in RDR1? What happens if you visit where Arthur died? In camp during Chap 6, whenever Micah would talk shit, I would just stand there face-to-face with him and smoke and drink and over-eat just so that Arthur would cough on him. Prior to Leopold Strauss' debt-collection mission, Downes can be seen on a street corner taking donations for charity and breaking up a bar fight before it turned fatal. See, I feel the opposite. Jan 13, 2021 路 Coughing on Micah possibly would’ve made no difference. Contraction didn’t necessarily mean certain death. But why didn’t Dutch Van der Linde, the leader of the Van der Linde gang, intervene to save his trusted member and friend? In chapter 3, Arthur gets captured by Colm O’Driscoll from midday until night time. Did Arthur Morgan survive in Red Dead Redemption 2? Unfortunately, there is no chance Jul 13, 2025 路 Unequivocally, yes. Ultimately, the game suggests that Arthur was doomed even if he had never contracted Tuberculosis. Feb 14, 2025 路 Why Didn’t Dutch Go With Micah? Understanding the Complex Motivations in Red Dead Redemption 2 The final confrontation in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a tense and dramatic affair. The situation can always end in gunfire but right now it's about trying to deescalate the situation. Chekhov's cough! Lmao. After Arthur and Micah beat each other into a stalemate he is in no condition to go anywhere anyway, because back then TB was a death sentence and as it progressed would take a severe physical toll. After the death of Arthur Morgan, John Marston, accompanied by Sadie Adler, finally tracks down the treacherous Micah Bell. Nov 28, 2018 路 In an early mission, Arthur has to collect a loan-shark debt from Thomas Downes, who was a poor farmer with a bad cough. Killing Micah in cold blood in camp would basically be an open rebellion against Dutch and end in either Dutch shooting Arthur or Arthur shooting Dutch and the gang either fracturing in violence or continuing on either under Dutch or Arthur but with a serious dark stain on it. I haven't had him chain smoking, is it part of the survival mechanics and can I fix it? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. What if Arthur Morgan never got sick in red dead redemption 2? What would happen if arthur didnt get sick in red dead redemption 2? What would have happened? Join the discord here: / discord Mar 3, 2025 路 Could Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick? Why is Arthur coughing so much? What are the visual signs of Arthur’s TB? Can you prevent Arthur from dying in RDR2? Did Dutch shoot Micah because of Arthur? Why is Arthur Morgan not mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 1? What illness does Hosea have? What gives you the most honor in RDR2? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Nov 8, 2023 路 Did Arthur give everyone TB? This SECRET Mission Gets Arthur A Cure For Tuberculosis & The BEST Item In Red Dead Redemption 2! Did Micah get TB? What did the doctor inject Arthur with? Does Arthur lose weight when he gets TB? Why is Hosea coughing RDR2? Did Dutch know Micah was a rat? Did Dutch know Arthur was sick? Does Arthur know he has TB? Jun 28, 2024 路 What if Arthur didn t get sick? Arthur didn’t need a diagnosis to tell him that he was going to die; even if he somehow escaped being shot or hanged, his death is an inevitability. For some reason when I first played that mission, it felt really significant. Edit: I think there is actually blood in the cough Downes does into Arthur’s face, but the blood isn’t necessary to transmit the illness from one person to another. Even if Dutch didnt show up, Micah would have reached that gun first. When Arthur starts to have his redemption arc Micah begins to see him as weak and pathetic, and in the end decides he isn’t worth finishing off. Blacklung this, you raging Tuesday. Even if he does this mission before the mission where he gets sick, he would still cough. And while Arthur didn't particularly like him, I don't think that he saw him as the problem that he would eventually be. Arthur revenge (Spoilers) Why doesn’t Arthur cough on Micah and give him TB? 11 11 Share Sort by: Kill Micah? I mean he makes it pretty clear towards the end of the game that he holds no loyalty to Dutch anymore, he's dying and he wants to see John and the women and children move on to better lives. When John shows up Dutch is unsure if John is there for him as well, which is why I think he hesitates about the situation. Everything that happened in Guarma (as well as the harsh climate there) didn’t help his immune system either. They could've even shown Micah coughing in american venom because Arthur spit on him during the fight. Arthur Morgan, without the debilitating effects of tuberculosis (TB), would have almost certainly killed Micah Bell in the final showdown atop Mount Hagen. I think the pre-Strauss coughs are due to the lifestyle Arthur lives (drinking, smoking, getting shot, constantly running with smoker lungs etc). Micah saw Dutch coming and stopped. However, when the time comes for him to actually back up his big words, he frequently fails Unlike Downes, Arthur had manners and didn't cough in people's faces. There, they find a seemingly changed Dutch Van Der Linde, who, instead of siding with his Why didn t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn't serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). If the player has high honor, Arthur succumbs to his injuries and disease, dying peacefully while watching the sunrise; with low honor, Micah executes him. It's a tense situation and they're sitting on a powder keg. Nov 19, 2023 路 Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Arthur attempts to beat/threaten him. Jun 24, 2023 路 Did Arthur get sick in Guarma? Although Guarma is the time most players might say Arthur starts to seems unwell (deer/coyote vision, struggling to keep up with Dutch and the others while running away from the soldiers in the first mission there, some coughing, etc), I’d say it was before that. Apr 24, 2025 路 Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah?: Arthur was self-aware of his illness but tried to avoid coughing on others, including Micah, out of consideration for their health. Dutch demanding blind faith probably didn’t help much either. 5 JuanMarston TB can be spread through the air as well. Dec 8, 2024 路 Unlike Downes, Arthur had manners and didn’t cough in people’s faces. May 4, 2023 路 Why is Arthur coughing blood? In chapter 2, One of the debtors is a sick man named Thomas Downes. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming by. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming cbssportsgolazo 2,660,356 馃拃 #UCLToday Feb 1, 2023 路 Why did Dutch betray Arthur? Because he’s already been manipulated by Micah, Dutch believes it’s what needs done. There’s no way that Dutch didn’t notice Arthur was missing, and he couldn’t have known it was a trap considering he seemed to have no idea about it when Arthur gets back to camp. In what chapter does Arthur get diagnosed with TB? At the end of Chapter 5 of Red Dead Redemption 2 Jan 4, 2024 路 Red Dead Redemption 2 is littered with both subtle and overt foreshadowing, and Micah is one of the biggest sources of it in the story. he coughs before Strauss and the player assumes its due to the smoking/other stuff, then after Strauss it takes the persistent coughing fits and the coughs that We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. You can do everything else before doing this mission, and stop (create a second game save) there. Why didn't Arthur cough on Micah before he died lol Just did the mission where Cornwall is killed and it really pisses me off that no one actually gives a shit about Arthur. shubeika 38,754 How the makeup for the beautiful @turchyna. bozhena was created # Not to mention the weeks, hell, maybe month or 2 of actual gameplay with Arthur. Arthur was the backbone of the team and Dutch didn’t say a word about his TB. The answer is a resounding yes. May 10, 2025 路 Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was likely self-aware of his illness and tried to avoid coughing on his allies, but he was unaware of the severity until diagnosed by a doctor. After Arthur revealed that Micah was the true traitor, Dutch was in denial, unwilling to believe his protégé's allegations that Micah could possibly be disloyal. Additionally, how could Arthur have known that coughing on people infects them? May 16, 2025 路 57K likes, 166 comments - rdr. Oct 19, 2020 路 Micah found out on his own because of his coughing. Can Arthur avoid getting tuberculosis? Currently, the only known way for a player to even come close to saving Arthur from TB in RDR2 is by not Most people on their first playthrough are expecting Arthur to kill Micah. Nov 19, 2023 路 Could Arthur have killed Micah without TB? However, if Arthur Morgan had not contracted tuberculosis, it is possible that he would have been able to kill Micah Bell at the ending of Red Dead Redemption 2. Downes). Arthur would have to make sure to cough up blood directly into Micah’s face orifices. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming iog_arthur 353,805 May 11, 2025 路 Could Arthur Morgan Beat Micah Bell Without Tuberculosis? Absolutely. I. Not only did he get blood on Arthur, but he also got his contaminated saliva and aerosol droplets from his lungs in his face. Outlaws for life 馃 #reddeadredemption #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #dutchvanderlinde #western #wildwest #rockstargames #arthur #johnmarston #gaming". qnzpopxmkurwpniuedpcfhvlwamskjqhixnpfljuydfnqdbdcymzoksrymvyzxoyhqqifjyntn